Share this
Federal Judge Blocks ICE’s New Restrictions on F-1 CPT
by Niloofar Rahimi Zadeh updated on Nov 17, 2026 03:04:13 PM
On November 17, 2026, Judge Julia E. Kobick of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts paused SEVP’s August 2026 CPT guidance. That guidance said internships and other training qualify as Curricular Practical Training (CPT) only if they are required of every student in a degree program.
The court found the guidance was likely arbitrary and capricious, because SEVP reversed a position it had held since 1991 without acknowledging or explaining the change. While the case continues, SEVP may not enforce or apply the two broadcast messages.
This does not mean every school will immediately approve elective CPT again. Students still need authorization from their Designated School Official (DSO) before starting any CPT.
You can read the full memorandum and order published by AAU, or view it on the court docket via CourtListener.
Key Takeaways
- What was blocked: SEVP Broadcast Messages of August 12, 2026 (BCM 2608-01) and August 24, 2026 (BCM 2608-02).
- Two forms of relief:
- A stay under 5 U.S.C. § 705, meaning the broadcasts may not be enforced or applied pending judicial review.
- A preliminary injunction protecting the plaintiff associations and their members, including members’ employees and students.
- Why: SEVP likely violated the “change-in-position” doctrine. It did not acknowledge it was changing policy, did not explain why, and did not consider the reliance of schools and students.
- What did not change: The CPT regulation, 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(f)(10)(i), and the requirement for DSO authorization before you work.
- What’s next: The lawsuit continues. The court has not issued a final decision on whether SEVP’s reading of the regulation is ultimately lawful.
Table of Contents
- What did the judge decide?
- What were SEVP’s August 2026 CPT broadcasts?
- Why the court blocked the broadcasts
- Who is protected by the ruling?
- Can F-1 students do elective CPT again?
- What the ruling means for Day 1 CPT
- CPT lawsuit timeline
- What F-1 students should do now
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What Did the Judge Decide?
In Association of American Universities v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security (No. 1:26-cv-14520-JEK), the court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction and stay of agency action. The order was filed November 17, 2026.
The order contains three parts:
- Stay of agency action. SEVP’s August 12 and August 24, 2026 broadcast messages are stayed. They “may not be enforced or applied pending judicial review.”
- Preliminary injunction. DHS, ICE, the Department of Justice, and anyone acting in concert with them are barred from implementing or enforcing the broadcasts’ interpretation of 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(f)(10)(i). This protection covers the plaintiffs and each of their members, including members’ employees and students. It applies both going forward and to conduct and approvals that happened before the broadcasts were issued.
- No security bond is required.
The court declined two additional requests from the plaintiffs:
- An order requiring the government to rescind adverse actions already taken. The plaintiffs did not identify any specific adverse action that could be rescinded.
- An order requiring the government to send written notice of the ruling to all SEVP-certified schools.
The case was brought by four groups:
- Association of American Universities (AAU): 69 research universities
- Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration: nearly 600 colleges and universities
- Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts (AICUM): 55 institutions
- NAFSA: Association of International Educators: more than 9,000 members
What Were SEVP’s August 2026 CPT Broadcasts?
SEVP is the Student and Exchange Visitor Program, part of ICE within DHS. It sent two broadcast messages to DSOs at SEVP-certified schools.
August 12, 2026: “Reminder of Liability for DSOs Regarding CPT Authorization”
- Said SEVP was increasing scrutiny of CPT approvals.
- Stated that DSOs could authorize CPT only if the work was required for all students pursuing the degree.
- Warned DSOs that authorizations are made under penalty of perjury.
- Warned that noncompliance could lead to withdrawal of the school’s SEVP certification and potential penalties.
August 24, 2026: “Guidance for Designated School Officials regarding Curricular Practical Training”
- Stated that all students enrolled in the curriculum must participate in the practical training.
- Stated that CPT cannot be offered as part of an optional elective course.
The practical effect was large. The court gave this example: a law school could no longer authorize CPT for an F-1 law student to extern with a federal judge for academic credit, unless that externship was required of every J.D. student.
Schools responded by pausing, denying, or rescinding CPT. According to declarations cited in the ruling:
- Columbia University denied CPT to more than 120 international students for the fall term.
- At Grinnell College, at least 13 students lost fall internship opportunities.
- Cornell University and Michigan State University lost students who discontinued their programs, partly because of lost experiential learning.
- Other schools began rewriting curricula to make practical training mandatory for all students.
For how individual schools reacted, see our coverage of how universities responded to SEVP’s August CPT guidance.
Why the Court Blocked the Broadcasts
1. The broadcasts changed a 35-year-old interpretation
The court traced the government’s position back to 1991. When the CPT regulation was adopted, the agency then in charge (INS) explained that CPT includes training for which students earn academic credit.
The 1991 final rule also described students participating in required CPT “as soon as school begins” or in elective CPT after a period in status. The government repeated this reading in several later documents:
- INS cables in January and May 1992
- A 2013 SEVP newsletter
- SEVP training materials for DSOs from 2014 and 2022
Those materials stated that CPT must either be required by the curriculum or, if not required, earn the student academic credit. The August 2026 broadcasts dropped that second path.
2. SEVP did not acknowledge or explain the change
Under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), an agency may change its policy. When it does, it must:
- show it knows it is changing position,
- give good reasons for the new policy, and
- consider the serious reliance interests built on the old policy.
The August 12 broadcast was framed as a “reminder.” Neither broadcast mentioned the 1991 rulemaking or the prior guidance.
The court held that, whether or not the new reading is “correct,” it is inconsistent with the earlier one, and SEVP never recognized that inconsistency.
3. SEVP ignored reliance interests
Schools had designed curricula and employer partnerships around for-credit elective CPT. Students had chosen and paid for programs expecting CPT to be available, and some lost paid internships or financial support.
The court cited the Supreme Court’s DACA decision (DHS v. Regents, 2020). It held that SEVP had to weigh these interests and consider alternatives, and it did not.
4. The disclaimers did not prevent review
Both broadcasts said they were not “a rule or a final action.” The court held that this boilerplate language did not control. The broadcasts used mandatory language and threatened loss of SEVP certification and liability for DSOs, so they qualified as final agency action that courts can review.
What the government argued
DHS argued that the broadcasts did not create a new rule. In its view, they simply restated the existing CPT regulation, so no public notice-and-comment process was needed. Government lawyers also argued that students who could not get CPT could apply for pre-completion Optional Practical Training (OPT) instead.
The disagreement centers on the wording of 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(f)(10)(i), which describes CPT as “alternative work/study, internship, cooperative education, or any other type of required internship or practicum.” SEVP read the word “required” as applying to every type of training on that list. Critics, including immigration attorneys who wrote to SEVP in September, argued that “required” applies only to the last item, so elective internships and cooperative education can still qualify when they are part of the curriculum.
The court did not decide which reading is correct. It ruled only that SEVP likely changed its long-standing position without acknowledging or explaining the change.
Other findings
- Standing: Member institutions and DSOs were the direct targets of the broadcasts. They did not need to wait for an enforcement action before suing.
- Irreparable harm: The court found irreparable harm in three things: unrecoverable staff time spent overhauling curricula and answering students, the threat of losing SEVP certification, and the uncertainty that threat creates.
- Not decided yet: The court relied only on the arbitrary-and-capricious claim. It did not decide the plaintiffs’ other claims (retroactivity, contrary to law, and procedural invalidity).
- Late argument not considered: The government argued in court for a canon of interpretation called “reverse ejusdem generis,” which neither broadcast mentioned. The court did not address it, noting that agencies generally must stand on the reasons they gave at the time.
Who Is Protected by the Ruling?
| Type of relief | What it does | Who it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Stay (5 U.S.C. § 705) | The two broadcasts may not be enforced or applied while the case is reviewed | The court found nationwide relief appropriate, to avoid “chaos and confusion” from a party-only order |
| Preliminary injunction | DHS cannot implement or enforce the broadcasts’ CPT interpretation, including against past approvals | The four plaintiff groups and their members, including members’ employees and students |
If your school belongs to AAU, the Presidents’ Alliance, AICUM, or NAFSA (NAFSA membership often runs through a school’s international office staff), the injunction gives it additional protection. Ask your international student office whether your school is covered.
If your school is not a member, the broadcasts themselves are still stayed. Each school, however, decides its own CPT policy and how quickly to update it.
Can F-1 Students Do Elective CPT Again?
Possibly, but not automatically. The ruling removes the legal force of the broadcasts while the case continues. It does not require any school to resume approving elective, for-credit CPT.
The court also declined to order the government to notify every school.
Here is what to expect:
- Some schools may restore their pre-August CPT policies fairly quickly.
- Others may wait for further court proceedings, a possible appeal, or new SEVP guidance before changing course.
- Curriculum changes made since August, such as converting internships into required courses, may stay in place.
The rule that has not changed: You may not begin any CPT, paid or unpaid, until your DSO authorizes it and records it in SEVIS. You must also be issued an updated Form I-20.
What the Ruling Means for Day 1 CPT
This case was about elective, for-credit CPT: training that earns academic credit but is not required of every student. The ruling does not specifically discuss Day 1 CPT programs.
What is relevant:
- The CPT regulation still allows graduate students in programs that require immediate participation in practical training to begin CPT before completing one academic year. The August broadcasts did not remove that provision, and this ruling does not change it.
- SEVP’s broader oversight of CPT still applies. Schools offering Day 1 CPT must still show that the training is an integral part of an established curriculum.
For background, read our guide to 2026 CPT changes and Day 1 CPT rules and our Day 1 CPT FAQ.
CPT Lawsuit Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1991 | INS adopts the CPT regulation; its preamble treats for-credit training as CPT |
| 1992–2022 | INS cables, a 2013 SEVP newsletter, and 2014/2022 DSO training confirm that elective for-credit training qualifies |
| August 12, 2026 | SEVP Broadcast Message 2608-01 |
| August 24, 2026 | SEVP Broadcast Message 2608-02 |
| Fall 2026 | Schools deny or rescind CPT and revise curricula |
| October 5, 2026 | AAU, Presidents’ Alliance, AICUM, and NAFSA sue and request an injunction and stay |
| October 28, 2026 | Government files its opposition |
| November 6, 2026 | Hearing before Judge Kobick (our hearing coverage) |
| November 17, 2026 | Court grants the stay and preliminary injunction |
What F-1 Students Should Do Now
- Check your school’s official CPT page and email notices. Your international student office will decide whether and when to restore elective CPT.
- Do not start working on the strength of the news alone. Wait for written DSO authorization and an updated I-20.
- If your CPT was denied or rescinded this fall, ask your DSO whether the school will reconsider. The injunction covers members’ past approvals, but the school still controls new authorizations.
- Talk to your employer early. If timing slips, see what to do if your employer won’t sign CPT documents.
- Keep copies of your CPT authorizations, course enrollment, and employer letters.
- Get individual advice from your DSO or a qualified immigration attorney, especially if you have a pending H-1B petition or a change-of-status application.
Note that this ruling is separate from the court decision that vacated DHS’s Duration of Status rule. See our coverage of the Duration of Status ruling.
FAQ
Yes. On November 17, 2026, Judge Julia E. Kobick stayed SEVP’s August 12 and August 24, 2026 CPT broadcast messages. She also preliminarily enjoined DHS from enforcing their interpretation against the plaintiff associations and their members. The ruling is preliminary; the lawsuit continues.
There was never a regulation banning CPT. SEVP’s broadcasts narrowed which training schools could approve, and those broadcasts are now stayed. Whether your school resumes approving elective CPT is up to your school.
Only if your school decides to authorize it. The ruling removes the broadcasts’ legal force, but it does not order any school to approve elective CPT. Ask your DSO.
The stay applies to the broadcasts themselves, and the court found nationwide relief appropriate. The injunction adds protection for members of AAU, the Presidents’ Alliance, AICUM, and NAFSA, along with their employees and students.
No. It is a preliminary injunction and stay pending judicial review. The court found that the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on one claim. It has not entered a final judgment.
Preliminary injunctions can generally be appealed. As of November 17, 2026, we have not seen a report of an appeal. Check back for updates.
The case concerned elective, for-credit CPT. The regulation’s provision for graduate programs that require immediate practical training was not changed by the broadcasts or by this ruling.
The injunction bars enforcement of the broadcasts’ interpretation, including against approvals made before the broadcasts. The court, however, declined to order the government to rescind adverse actions. Reinstating a CPT authorization is a decision for your school.
No. The regulation, 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(f)(10)(i), is unchanged. The dispute is about how SEVP interpreted it in August 2026.
Pre-completion OPT is a separate benefit. It requires a USCIS application and counts against your 12-month OPT allowance. Ask your DSO whether it fits your situation.
Sources:
- Bloomberg Law, “ICE Foreign Student Internship Limit Blocked as Case Proceeds”: https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/ice-foreign-student-internship-limit-blocked-as-case-proceeds
- Reuters via Yahoo News, “US judge blocks Trump policy restricting foreign student work options”: https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/us-judge-blocks-trump-policy-171541708.html
- The Korea Times (Reuters syndication): https://www.koreatimes.co.kr/world/20261118/us-judge-blocks-trump-policy-restricting-foreign-student-work-options
- American Immigration Council, CPT litigation summary: https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/blog/trump-targets-f-1-students-turmoil/
Share this
- Day 1 CPT Universities (96)
- H-1B Status (64)
- F-1 Status (32)
- GoElite Insights (32)
- Immigration (25)
- Visa & Status (23)
- Green card (20)
- USCIS (20)
- OPT (17)
- DHS Rule (13)
- Day 1 CPT (12)
- Layoff (10)
- Change of Status (9)
- Perm (7)
- student visa (6)
- RFE (5)
- L1 (4)
- Employers (1)
- L1 Visa (1)
- Visa Reentry (1)
